Section 588FA Unfair Preference Claims 2026
Review a client’s payment records for a section 588FA claim, with transaction dates, supporting accounts and the limits of the accountant’s conclusion.
- Published
- Updated
An unfair preference claim concerns a company transaction that gives a creditor more for an unsecured debt than the creditor would receive in a winding up.
Build a supported payment history for the client’s legal adviser. An overdue invoice or a payment received before liquidation does not, by itself, establish a recoverable preference.
What Section 588FA Tests
Section 588FA of the Corporations Act 2001 requires the company and creditor to be parties to the transaction. The creditor must receive the preferential benefit for an unsecured debt owed by that company.
A secured debt counts as unsecured to the extent its amount exceeds the security’s value. Retain the security documents and valuation evidence instead of treating a security registration as a complete answer.
Recovery also depends on the insolvency and voidability provisions. Section 588FC addresses transactions entered into or given effect during insolvency, or causing insolvency. Section 588FE supplies the applicable statutory circumstances and periods.
The ordinary six-month period ends on the relation-back day. Other circumstances have different rules. Record the appointment history and leave the applicable period and any court-application deadline to the legal adviser.
Facts Behind the Claim
Identify the debtor company by its legal name and company number. Then identify the creditor, invoice issuer, payer and recipient. A group trading name or payment reference can hide a payment involving another entity.
For each disputed receipt, collect the payment instruction, bank entry and allocation to the debt. Retain third-party payment arrangements. Flag any mismatch between the company said to owe the debt and the account that paid it.
Collect the accounts and cash records relevant to the alleged insolvency period. Include aged payables, cash forecasts, unpaid liabilities and available finance. Separate documents created at the time from explanations prepared after the company failed.
The accountant can establish what the records show. Whether the company was legally insolvent, or a creditor received more than in the hypothetical winding up, requires a wider assessment than one supplier’s account.
Other Voidable Transactions
An unfair preference concerns a creditor’s advantage on its debt. Uncommercial transactions, unfair loans and unreasonable director-related transactions have separate statutory tests. Keep the claim’s pleaded basis beside each transaction so different claims do not become one unexplained total.
Build the Payment and Account Timeline
Reconcile the full account chronologically, including supplies and credits as well as receipts. Starting with a list of bank deposits can omit the trading activity that explains a continuing business relationship.
- Preserve the original customer account and bank exports before changing allocations. Record the source system, export period and opening balance.
- Match invoices to supply records, agreed terms and the correct debtor. Keep invoice dates separate from delivery and posting dates.
- Match every receipt to bank evidence and remittance advice. Record reversals, dishonours and split allocations separately.
- Trace credit notes to their reason and authorisation. Distinguish a returned supply from a correction or disputed invoice.
- Reconcile the closing balance to the account statement. Keep unexplained differences in a separate list with their supporting documents.
Give each row a document reference. Include both the transaction date and the bank clearing date where they differ. Preserve original allocations alongside any proposed correction so another reviewer can follow the change.
Continuing Business Relationships
In Bryant v Badenoch Integrated Logging Pty Ltd, the High Court rejected the peak-indebtedness rule. A liquidator cannot simply choose the highest account balance within the period to maximise the claimed reduction.
Section 588FA(3) can treat transactions forming part of a continuing business relationship as one transaction. The assessment considers the commercial character of the relationship, including continuing supplies and payments that increase and reduce indebtedness.
The High Court identifies the starting transaction by the prescribed period, insolvency and when the relationship began. Use the first qualifying transaction after the latest relevant starting point. The legal adviser must settle those boundaries from the evidence.
Whether a payment belongs to the relationship is an objective factual inquiry. The parties’ intentions can be relevant, but do not decide the issue alone. Preserve correspondence about further supply, credit holds and arrangements to clear old debt.
An account remaining open in the software does not prove the relationship continued. Show when supplies stopped, whether any resumed and what the parties actually agreed. Payments after the relationship ended need separate attention.
A Fictional Running Account
Assume the legal adviser identifies the following transactions as one continuing relationship within the relevant period. The example illustrates account reconciliation only. It does not establish insolvency, a preference or the recoverable amount.
| Event | Account movement | Amount owed |
|---|---|---|
| Opening debt | Opening balance | $20,000 |
| Further supply | Add $15,000 | $35,000 |
| Payment received | Deduct $12,000 | $23,000 |
| Further supply | Add $8,000 | $31,000 |
| Payment received | Deduct $15,000 | $16,000 |
The client receives $27,000 while providing $23,000 of further supplies. The debt falls by $4,000 from the opening balance. Comparing the $35,000 peak with the $16,000 closing balance would instead produce $19,000.
The $19,000 figure uses the rejected peak starting point. The $4,000 difference is an accounting movement for the assumed relationship. Neither number, on its own, decides liability.
If a credit note or payment belongs outside that relationship, retain it in the overall timeline and identify the proposed treatment. Do not delete it to make the running-account arithmetic fit.
Prepare the Client’s Evidence
Prepare an indexed response that separates supported facts from assumptions and legal conclusions. Give the client’s legal adviser the claim letter and its response deadline before completing the accounting work.
The Australian Securities and Investments Commission’s creditor guide says creditors can request the alleged preference payments, reasons and supporting evidence. A demand for repayment needs assessment before the client accepts it.
Document Response Checklist
- Keep the demand, attachments and later correspondence together. Identify each transaction and amount the claimant challenges.
- Include contracts, credit terms and security documents, with evidence of the parties’ identities.
- Provide the complete account timeline, original exports and bank reconciliations. Cross-reference invoices, delivery records, credits and remittances.
- Include communications about payment promises, supply holds, returned payments and changes to trading terms.
- Separate missing documents and contested allocations from agreed balances. Identify who can explain each unresolved item.
- Record the proposed response owner and deadline. Let the legal adviser decide what to provide and how to protect confidential material.
Facts Relevant to a Defence
ASIC explains that good faith and grounds for suspecting insolvency are relevant to a creditor’s defence. Preserve what the creditor actually knew when each transaction occurred, alongside the information available to a reasonable person in those circumstances.
Retain credit checks, payment explanations and correspondence about funding. Keep evidence of dishonours and repeated broken promises too. A file that contains only favourable messages can hide facts the legal adviser needs to assess.
Section 588FG(2) also addresses valuable consideration or a change of position in reliance on the transaction. Give the legal adviser the supply records and evidence of any claimed change of position. Receiving payment of a genuine invoice is insufficient alone.
Keep Findings Within the Evidence
Write “bank statement records a receipt of $12,000” when the bank entry supports it. Record “customer says the payment covered later supplies” as an account requiring support. Leave “payment is protected from recovery” as a legal conclusion.
Return the reconciled schedule with its document index, unresolved items and clearly stated assumptions. The legal adviser can then assess the statutory elements, relationship boundaries and defence facts without mistaking an accounting balance for a liability verdict.
One client form. One finished return.
Your client completes one guided form. Tax Genie checks it, chases mistakes and sends the details to your engagement letter and tax software.
Made for Australian accounting firms