Safe Harbour From ATO Penalties: Agent Errors

The ATO safe harbour protects a client from some penalties when their tax or BAS agent made the mistake. See when it applies and what the agent must show.

Published
Updated

Safe harbour can exempt your client from certain ATO penalties for agent errors if they gave their registered tax or BAS agent all relevant information.

What the ATO Safe Harbour Covers

The safe harbour has two separate tests under Schedule 1 to the Taxation Administration Act 1953. Start with the reason on the penalty notice.

False or Misleading Statements

Subsection 284-75(6) can protect the client when the registered agent makes a materially false or misleading statement after receiving all relevant tax information. The usual case is an error caused by the agent’s failure to take reasonable care.

For example, a client gives their agent a complete set of statements showing bank interest. The agent overlooks one statement and lodges a return that understates the client’s tax. The client can point to the records they supplied.

The ATO’s guidance on statement penalties explains the shortfall case. The statute can also cover certain false or misleading statements without a tax shortfall.

Failure to Lodge on Time

Subsection 286-75(1A) can apply if the client gave the registered agent all relevant tax information in time to lodge in the approved form by the due date.

The protection can apply even if the agent took reasonable care and still missed the deadline.

Suppose your client sends every record and the signed declaration two weeks before the due date, then your team overlooks the job. Confirm the due date for that client under the tax agent lodgment program, including any approved deferral.

The ATO explains both safe harbours for agents. The Tax Practitioners Board (TPB) guidance explains the provisions for taxpayers and confirms that the ATO decides whether they apply.

When the Safe Harbour Does Not Apply

The client loses the protection if the agent’s recklessness or intentional disregard of the tax law caused the failure. The client must also show that they supplied all the relevant information.

If a client withheld an interest statement needed to report their income correctly, the statement safe harbour fails. The same applies if they supplied incorrect or conflicting information needed to prepare the return.

For late lodgment, check when the agent received the last item needed to lodge. The client must meet the practice’s deadlines for providing the information, including any signed declaration required for lodgment.

The safe harbour applies to the specified administrative penalties. The underlying tax and any applicable interest charges remain payable. Check the notice for separate amounts, particularly when an amendment increases the client’s tax.

What the Practice Must Show

The client must be able to show what they gave the registered agent and when. Build the timeline from records created while the work was under way.

  • Keep the engagement letter and client instructions showing what the agent agreed to prepare and lodge.
  • Save the client’s original records and messages. Keep upload receipts or email timestamps that link each document to the date it arrived.
  • Record your requests for missing information and when the client answered. Include any required signed declaration.
  • Keep the applicable due date, any deferral confirmation and the lodgment receipt. For a statement error, retain the version lodged and the working papers that show where the error arose.

Raise safe harbour for a false or misleading statement with the ATO officer handling the review or audit. Point to the original information, show the item the agent got wrong and explain how the mistake occurred.

If the ATO has already assessed a statement penalty, include the safe harbour grounds in the objection. Check the ATO’s objection deadlines against the notice.

For late lodgment, the ATO accepts safe harbour requests through Practice mail in Online services for agents. Select Debt and lodgment, then “Cancellation of FTL penalty (safe harbour)”.

The ATO can accept your confirmation as evidence that the client gave you everything in time. Explain why your practice lodged late so the ATO can decide whether the protection applies.

If a late lodgment penalty remains, ATO penalty remission is a separate request for the Commissioner to reduce or waive an assessed penalty under section 298-20. Explain what caused the delay and what the client did to comply.

For late lodgment, submit the ATO’s remission form through Practice mail. Keep the ATO’s response with the notice. If the ATO declines remission, check any objection rights and deadlines in its decision.

The Agent’s Own Exposure

The ATO can refer the agent to the TPB after granting safe harbour. The Board can investigate a possible breach of the Code of Professional Conduct under the Tax Agent Services Act 2009.

If it finds a breach, the TPB can issue a caution, order training or suspend registration. It can also terminate registration.

The Board says in its complaints guidance that it cannot order the practitioner to reimburse the client’s ATO penalties or interest.

If an error could cause a client loss, review your professional indemnity policy. Notify the insurer promptly in writing if the facts could give rise to a claim. The ATO’s decision can come later.

Follow the policy’s notice requirements and report within the policy period where applicable. Save the original records and the notice to the insurer with the chronology you use to show the ATO what happened.

One client form. One finished return.

Your client completes one guided form. Tax Genie checks it, chases mistakes and sends the details to your engagement letter and tax software.

See how Tax Genie works

Made for Australian accounting firms

Tax GenieSee how Tax Genie works