Reasonably Arguable Position for Tax Work 2026
Assess a reasonably arguable tax position using client facts and relevant authorities. Retain the analysis and distinguish it from other penalty tests.
- Published
- Updated
A reasonably arguable position is a tax treatment supported by authorities strongly enough to be about as likely to be correct as incorrect, or better.
To assess your client’s position, settle the facts first. Compare the competing legal arguments and retain a conclusion that another reviewer can follow.
Identify the Relevant Test
Start with the taxpayer, disputed issue and relevant income year. Identify the proposed treatment and the statement in which it will appear. Separate uncertain facts from uncertainty about the law.
Section 284-15 of Schedule 1 to the Taxation Administration Act sets the objective standard. The taxpayer’s confidence in an argument does not establish its strength.
For an ordinary income-tax shortfall, item 4 of section 284-90 sets a 25% base penalty where the treatment fails that standard and the shortfall exceeds the applicable threshold.
The ordinary threshold is the greater of $10,000 or 1% of income tax payable on the return. Trusts and partnerships have separate rules, using $20,000 and 2% of returned net income.
Assess the correct statutory item before calculating exposure. Minimum Tax and petroleum resource rent tax also have relevant provisions. Scheme penalties and transfer pricing require their own analysis.
Keep the Other Tests Separate
Reasonable care concerns how the taxpayer and agent meet their obligations in their circumstances. A reasonably arguable position concerns the objective strength of the legal argument. Document each assessment separately.
The ATO’s shortfall-penalty guidance explains the different penalty grounds. Passing the reasonably-arguable test does not guarantee that every penalty provision is satisfied or remove the underlying tax shortfall.
Disclosure tells the ATO about the treatment. It does not make a weak argument reasonably arguable. Voluntary disclosure can affect penalty reductions, which require a separate assessment.
A private ruling binds the ATO where it applies to the taxpayer and the taxpayer relies on it. A practice’s position paper has a different function.
If the actual arrangement differs materially from the ruling’s facts, its protection does not apply. Consider a ruling application where the client needs the Commissioner’s binding view before acting.
Weigh the Facts and Authorities
Build the argument from the applicable legislation. Include interpretation materials and relevant decisions, then examine public rulings. Record the version of the law that applies to the client’s period.
For each authority, explain the legal proposition it supports and how the client’s facts compare. A higher-court decision on the same issue carries different weight from an unrelated tribunal decision.
Read the reasoning and outcome together. A favourable sentence taken from different facts cannot carry the whole conclusion. Identify contrary authorities and explain whether they defeat the argument or can be distinguished.
The ATO’s MT 2008/2 ruling discusses the balanced approach in Walstern and Pridecraft. Losing the substantive tax argument does not, by itself, settle the reasonably-arguable question.
Counsel’s opinion can explain the analysis. The opinion itself is not a relevant authority: examine the legislation and authorities supporting it, including any factual assumptions that counsel makes.
Fictional Position-Paper Exercise
Suppose a business wants to deduct expenditure incurred while replacing part of an income-producing asset. The initial file contains an invoice described as repairs and a favourable passage from a ruling.
An inadequate conclusion reads, “The invoice says repairs, so the deduction is reasonably arguable.” It leaves the actual work and competing capital treatment unexplained.
A better file identifies what was replaced, its condition before the work and whether the work improved the asset. Retain the contract and a description of the work performed.
The analysis then compares the repair argument with the capital argument under the applicable law. Explain which facts each argument needs and how the authorities treat those facts.
In this fictional file, the reviewer declines approval because the work description is missing and the capital argument remains unanswered. Obtain that evidence and complete the comparison before reaching a reasonably-arguable conclusion.
Retain and Revisit the Position
Keep a position paper that connects the client’s evidence with the conclusion. Use the following file checklist so a reviewer can reconstruct the decision.
- Record the entity, income year, issue and proposed return treatment, including the amount at risk.
- Attach supporting documents and distinguish confirmed facts from assumptions. Record the client’s answers to unresolved factual questions.
- Retain the legislation and research references, with relevant passages and the competing interpretations.
- Explain contrary authorities and why the proposed argument survives them, or why it fails.
- State the conclusion, its factual conditions and the separate penalty analysis. Record the reviewer’s approval and the client advice given.
MT 2008/2 assesses the position when the statement is made. Outside transfer pricing, the general penalty provisions do not require a contemporaneous written position paper, but retaining one makes the reasoning traceable.
Transfer pricing has specific documentation requirements. A general file checklist cannot replace those requirements.
Revisit the paper if client facts change or a legislative amendment or later decision affects the analysis. Preserve the earlier version and explain the effect on both the original period and future statements.
Tell the client what action follows: provide missing evidence, change a future treatment or assess whether an earlier return needs correction. Refer disputed legal questions for specialist review before approving continued use.
If a penalty has already been assessed, ATO penalty remission is a separate task. Keep the merits of the tax position distinct from the grounds for reducing that penalty.
The final check is practical: another reviewer must be able to identify the argument, trace its facts and explain why the conclusion follows before the practice relies on it.
One client form. One finished return.
Your client completes one guided form. Tax Genie checks it, chases mistakes and sends the details to your engagement letter and tax software.
Made for Australian accounting firms