Notice of Assessment: Accountant Checks 2026

Does the tax assessment match the return you lodged? Reconcile taxable income, offsets, credits and account movements before explaining the balance.

Published
Updated

A notice of assessment shows the ATO’s calculation of your client’s tax. Reconcile it with the lodged return, then trace any difference in the account balance.

Read the Assessment With the Lodged Return

Use the filed version for the same client and income year. Keep the lodgment receipt beside that version so a later working draft cannot become your comparison by mistake.

The ATO’s notice of assessment guidance explains what the notice contains. It shows assessed tax, credits for tax already paid and the resulting refund or amount payable.

Record the income year and the issue date shown on the assessment. Use both to identify the notice if the ATO issued more than one for that year.

Keep these documents separate when assembling the file.

DocumentWhat it tells youReconciliation use
Income statementEmployer-reported pay and withholdingSupports employment figures in the return
Lodged tax returnInformation sent to the ATOEstablishes the version being assessed
Notice of assessmentATO assessment calculationShows the assessed outcome
Statement of accountDebits, credits and account balanceExplains movements beyond that assessment

For individuals, work from income and deductions to taxable income. Then compare tax on that income, non-refundable offsets and other liabilities. Check refundable offsets and credits separately. Use the detailed return calculation to explain figures the notice summarises.

Use the rules for the relevant income year and taxpayer. Medicare levy, Medicare levy surcharge and study-loan repayments need their own checks where they apply. A matching taxable income does not establish that every component of the assessment matches.

The ATO’s explanation of the tax calculation separates these components. A non-refundable offset reduces tax under its applicable rules. It is not automatically a cash credit available to pay every other liability.

If the client needs their own copy, the ATO provides retrieval instructions through linked myGov services. Use the notice for the relevant year, including any amended assessment. The client’s income statement is a different document.

Reconcile Credits and the Account Balance

Separate the assessment result from the account movements that determine what the client must pay or receives. A smaller bank deposit does not, by itself, establish an error in assessed income or deductions.

First reconcile PAYG withholding to the income statements or payment summaries used in the return. Match PAYG instalment credits to the relevant instalment records. Keep tax offsets separate from payments so the same amount is not counted twice.

Trace the assessment into the account. Start with the opening balance and identify each transfer, refund, payment, interest entry or penalty. Record the account and income year for each movement.

If you see “Income tax 001” in ATO tax accounts, use the full account label and match its transactions to the notice. The account records payments and transfers alongside assessment entries.

The ATO issues a statement of account when the account balance differs from the assessment outcome. Its guidance includes existing balances, interest and credits applied against other debts among the reasons.

An assessment credit can pay a debt. See how the ATO applies refunds to debts, including certain debts with other government agencies. Match the offset to its transaction.

Finish with two figures in the workpaper: the assessment refund or payable amount, and the reconciled account outcome. Identify which document carries the payment advice and due date.

Find and Correct an Assessment Difference

Investigate a difference in order, starting with the filed version and ending with the correction route supported by the evidence.

  1. Confirm the client, income year and assessment version. Compare the original assessment with any amended notice before treating a change as unexplained.
  2. Compare each calculation component with the lodged return. Record the first line that differs and its amount. If assessed tax matches, move to credits and account transactions.
  3. Compare the prefill retained at lodgment with later source information. An updated employer statement can change the underlying facts. Ask the employer to correct an incorrect income statement.
  4. Read any ATO adjustment correspondence. Match its reason to the changed assessment line. For a missing credit, retain evidence of the withholding, instalment or payment and check its allocation.
  5. Choose the correction route. Record who will act, the evidence required and the applicable time limit. Keep the payment obligation under review while the difference is investigated.

The ATO explains that income statement figures can change before finalisation. A later prefill figure is a reason to investigate. It does not prove that the ATO automatically replaced the lodged figure.

Use the ATO’s amendment guidance to distinguish the next action. Correct a mistake or omission in the return through an amendment once processing is complete and within the applicable time limit.

For a suspected processing error, contact the ATO with the return and assessment. For a payment or allocation problem, raise an account enquiry with transaction evidence.

Use an objection to dispute an ATO decision on facts or law.

Record when the ATO sent or gave the notice to your client or their representative. Use the ATO’s amendment periods and objection time limits for this taxpayer and decision. An account enquiry leaves those deadlines running.

Give the Client a Clear Explanation

Explain the confirmed cause of the difference and what happens next. Keep an unresolved hypothesis out of a statement that the assessment is correct.

Consider this fictional reconciliation. The lodged calculation and assessment both show taxable income of $80,000. For this illustration, assume tax and other assessed liabilities total $16,000, with $19,000 of withholding credits and no other assessment components.

These are assumed totals for demonstrating reconciliation, not a tax-rate calculation for a particular income year.

Fictional Refund Reconciliation

Reconciliation itemAmountWhat the practitioner confirms
Assessed liabilities$16,000Matches the lodged calculation
Withholding credits$19,000Matches the income records
Assessment refund$3,000$19,000 less $16,000
Credit applied to an existing debt$700Supported by the account transaction
Remaining refund$2,300$3,000 less $700

An incorrect explanation is that the ATO reduced the client’s deductions by $700. The confirmed explanation is that assessed tax matches the return and $700 of the refund pays an existing debt.

The client explanation can read: “Your assessment matches the return we lodged. It produces a $3,000 refund. The ATO applied $700 against your existing debt, leaving $2,300 to refund. This reconciliation leaves no further payment due.”

Keep the lodged version and receipt with the assessment, account transactions and calculation. Retain the evidence for the existing debt and the client explanation. Close the task when the account and refund agree, or assign the remaining enquiry.

One client form. One finished return.

Your client completes one guided form. Tax Genie checks it, chases mistakes and sends the details to your engagement letter and tax software.

See how Tax Genie works

Made for Australian accounting firms

Tax GenieSee how Tax Genie works