Non-Commercial Losses: Client Review 2026

Can your client offset a business loss or must it be deferred? Check the income requirement, business tests and exception evidence before claiming.

Published
Updated

Non-commercial losses from an individual’s business are deferred unless an exception applies, or the individual meets the income requirement and a business test, or obtains Commissioner’s discretion.

Start With the Business Activity

Identify a business before applying Division 35. A hobby does not become a business because the client wants to deduct its costs.

Consider the commercial purpose and prospect of profit. Examine regular trading, scale and business records alongside how similar operators work. The Australian Taxation Office (ATO) weighs these factors together in its business guidance.

A loss can arise in a genuine business. The non-commercial loss rules then decide when the excess deductions can reduce other income.

Record the activity and the income year. Identify whether the client operates alone or as an individual partner. Reconcile assessable income with otherwise allowable deductions before calculating the activity’s tax loss.

Keep unrelated activities separate. Similar business activities can be grouped where the facts support that treatment. Document why they are similar instead of combining every activity to reach an income threshold.

Partnership treatment requires a separate review for each individual partner. For the income and asset tests, interests attributable to individual partners can be aggregated. Interests belonging to companies or trustees are excluded.

A partner’s own qualifying income or assets can also matter. The profits test considers the individual’s share and their attributable deductions. One partner’s result does not automatically establish another’s entitlement.

Business Expenses in a Year Without Income

Your client can have deductible expenses even if their business earned no income that year. Check whether the business has begun operating and whether its expenses qualify under section 8-1 or another deduction rule.

Check setup costs separately. If otherwise allowable deductions create a loss for a sole trader, Division 35 decides whether your client can use it against salary or other income that year. If no offset route applies, defer the loss.

Income Requirement and Business Tests

For the usual four-test route, the individual’s income for non-commercial loss purposes must be less than $250,000. Passing an activity test alone does not overcome a failed income requirement.

Add taxable income, total reportable fringe benefits, reportable superannuation contributions and total net investment losses.

Calculate taxable income ignoring business losses subject to Division 35 and any assessable first home super saver (FHSS) released amount. The ATO’s income requirement instructions explain these adjustments.

For example, assume taxable income after these adjustments is $230,000. Reportable fringe benefits are $12,000 and reportable superannuation contributions are $10,000, with no net investment losses. The total is $252,000, so the income requirement fails.

Once the income requirement is met, passing one test is enough. Use tax figures and the required asset valuations, with records showing how you calculated them.

Four Business Tests

TestPassing conditionEvidence to retain
Assessable incomeActivity assessable income of at least $20,000Sales records and other assessable amounts, excluding goods and services tax (GST)
ProfitsTax profit in at least three of five income years, including the current yearFive-year tax reconciliation, excluding prior deferred losses when testing each year’s profit
Real propertyAt least $500,000 of qualifying real property used continuously in the activityOwnership or lease evidence and reduced cost base or market valuation
Other assetsAt least $100,000 of qualifying other assets used continuously in the activityAsset register and the applicable tax valuation calculations

For part-year trading, a reasonable full-year income estimate can satisfy the assessable income test. Support the estimate with orders and seasonal trading evidence. A mechanical annualisation can misstate the activity’s likely income.

The real property test excludes a mainly private dwelling and its related private land, plus tenant-owned fixtures. Other assets exclude real property and cars, motorcycles or similar vehicles. Apportion mixed-use assets and apply the specified valuation rules.

The ATO’s four tests guidance explains these exclusions and valuation methods. A high purchase price alone does not prove that the other-assets threshold is met.

Exceptions and Commissioner’s Discretion

A primary production or professional arts business can qualify for the statutory exception when other assessable income is below $40,000, excluding net capital gains. This uses assessable income, not the $250,000 income calculation.

At exactly $40,000, that exception fails. Classify the business correctly and reconcile its unrelated income before relying on the ATO’s excepted activities guidance.

Where no automatic route applies, Commissioner’s discretion can address qualifying special circumstances or an inherent business lead time. An application does not itself authorise a loss offset.

Special circumstances must be outside the operator’s control. Explain how the event affects the relevant test or tax profit, using evidence of the activity’s position without that event.

For inherent lead time, show that the activity has commenced and its nature delays the required result. Starting small or slowly building a client base does not establish this ground.

Support the expected result with independent industry evidence where available. Explain when a test or tax profit is expected within the industry’s commercially viable period. For someone failing the income requirement, the lead-time route requires an expected tax profit.

The ATO’s private ruling application guidance explains the required circumstances. Retain the application and the decision separately. Match any favourable decision to the activity and income years it covers.

Carry Forward a Deferred Loss

A deferred loss stays with its business activity and is reconsidered in a later year. It can reduce later income from that activity before any remaining loss is tested against other income.

Keep a separate balance for each activity. Reconcile the opening deferred loss with the prior return, amounts used and any new loss deferred. Record any reduction for net exempt income that has not already absorbed ordinary tax losses.

The ATO’s deferral guidance explains how the balance carries forward. A salary increase, business cessation or change in activity needs a fresh assessment before claiming a remaining amount elsewhere.

Worked Client Loss Record

Consider this fictional sole trader’s repair business. Assume it is a genuine business throughout, no exception or discretion applies, and the client has no exempt income.

In Year 1, a full year of trading produces $12,000 assessable income and $20,000 allowable deductions. The $8,000 loss is deferred because the client meets the income requirement but fails all four tests.

In Year 2, income is $18,000 and current deductions are $15,000. The activity’s $3,000 profit absorbs part of the deferred $8,000. Assume no other test passes. The remaining $5,000 stays deferred.

In Year 3, income is $25,000 and current deductions are $28,000. Add the $5,000 deferred balance to the current $3,000 loss. The total loss available for the Division 35 assessment is $8,000.

Assume the client still meets the income requirement. The activity now passes the $20,000 assessable income test, so the $8,000 can reduce other income. The deferred balance closes at zero.

If the client instead fails the Year 3 income requirement, the assessable income test alone does not release the $8,000. Reassess the exception and discretion routes before deferring the amount again.

For the return file, retain the business evidence and yearly reconciliation with the chosen treatment. Confirm that the closing deferred balance agrees with the return and next year’s opening record before finalising the claim.

One client form. One finished return.

Your client completes one guided form. Tax Genie checks it, chases mistakes and sends the details to your engagement letter and tax software.

See how Tax Genie works

Made for Australian accounting firms

Tax GenieSee how Tax Genie works