Insolvent Trading: What Directors Must Know
Insolvent trading can expose directors to personal liability. See what it means, the warning signs, the safe harbour and what advisers do.
- Published
- Updated
Insolvent trading occurs when a company incurs a debt while unable to pay its debts as they fall due, or the new debt makes it insolvent.
Directors risk personal liability if they fail to prevent the debt and knew or ought reasonably to have known of grounds to suspect insolvency.
What Insolvent Trading Means
Section 588G of the Corporations Act 2001 applies to the person who was a director when the company incurred the debt.
For a civil breach, the director must have known of grounds for suspicion or a reasonable director in the same circumstances would have known.
Consider a company already behind on tax and supplier bills. It orders more stock on credit even though its cash forecast shows it cannot meet existing debts.
The order can expose the directors to a claim before the new invoice falls due.
A court can order compensation for losses caused by the breach and disqualify a director from managing companies.
For an individual, the maximum civil penalty is the greater of 5,000 penalty units or three times the benefit gained and detriment avoided, if the court can determine that amount.
A dishonest failure to prevent a debt when the director suspected insolvency can be a criminal offence.
An individual faces up to five years’ imprisonment, a fine of up to 2,000 penalty units or both. ASIC’s guidance on insolvent trading consequences
The ATO can separately issue a director penalty notice for unpaid PAYG withholding, GST or super guarantee charge.
Warning Signs of Insolvency
Cash shortfalls, overdue obligations and tighter supplier terms can all point to insolvency. Compare payment dates with cash the company can actually access and receipts it can reasonably expect.
- Tax arrears or missing lodgments. Reconcile the ATO account with outstanding returns and activity statements. Unreported liabilities can leave the books understating what the company owes.
- Suppliers on stop supply. Identify who has refused further credit or now requires cash on delivery. Check what must be paid before new stock can arrive.
- Missed wages or super. Compare scheduled payments with cleared bank transactions. Include overdue entitlements and the next payroll in the cash forecast.
- Receipts slipping or credit running out. Check when customers are likely to pay and whether lenders have committed to making funds available in time.
If the forecast shows a shortfall, flag it to the directors promptly and identify which new debts the company is about to incur.
Give an insolvency adviser the forecast, bank balances and aged debtors and creditors so they can assess the timing.
The Directors’ Safe Harbour
Under section 588GA, safe harbour can protect directors from civil insolvent trading liability.
Once a director suspects the company is or may become insolvent, the protected period can begin when the director starts developing a qualifying course of action.
The course of action must be reasonably likely to leave the company better off than the immediate appointment of an administrator or liquidator.
The protection can cover debts incurred directly or indirectly for that course of action or in the ordinary course of business during the protected period.
Directors relying on safe harbour must point to evidence that the conditions applied to the debt.
Keep employee entitlements, including super, paid as they fall due and lodge all required tax documents.
A substantial failure to comply, or a current failure that is one of at least two in 12 months, can bar protection unless the court grants relief.
A later failure to comply substantially with certain duties to provide information or assist an external administrator can also defeat protection. ASIC’s safe harbour guidance
- Establish the cash position. Update the records, forecast when debts fall due and check whether payroll, super and tax reporting are up to date.
- Compare the available outcomes. Estimate what the company could achieve through a funded turnaround and what immediate administration or liquidation would produce. Record the assumptions supporting the comparison.
- Put the plan into effect. Set deadlines for funding, creditor agreements or business changes. Minute the board’s decisions and record why new debts arise as the plan runs.
- Review each milestone. Reforecast when expected funding or receipts slip. Protection can end if directors delay implementation unreasonably, stop pursuing the plan or appoint an administrator or liquidator. It also ends if the better outcome is no longer reasonably likely.
Give an appropriately qualified, insured insolvency or restructuring adviser complete financial and operating records. They can test the forecasts and assess whether the plan stands a reasonable chance of delivering a better outcome.
The directors remain responsible for the decision.
An adviser can also assess whether an eligible company could use small business debt restructuring to put a formal plan to creditors.
Defences and Claims
Section 588H gives directors four defences to a civil insolvent trading claim. The director must prove the facts behind the defence.
- Reasonable expectation of solvency. The director reasonably expected the company was solvent and would remain solvent. That expectation had to account for all debts the company incurred and all property it disposed of at the time.
- Reliance on a competent, reliable person. The director reasonably believed that person was responsible for giving adequate solvency information and was doing so. The information led the director to expect the company was solvent and would remain solvent despite those debts and disposals.
- Illness or another good reason kept the director out of the company’s management when the debt was incurred.
- The director took all reasonable steps to prevent the company incurring the debt. Steps towards appointing an administrator or restructuring practitioner can be relevant.
After a voluntary liquidation begins, the liquidator can bring a section 588M claim in court.
The liquidator uses ledgers, contracts and bank statements to establish when insolvency began and when each debt arose. Company records can also show what the director knew at the time.
The liquidator must establish that the creditor suffered loss because of the insolvency and the debt was wholly or partly unsecured when the creditor suffered the loss.
The liquidator has six years from the start of the winding up to bring the claim.
A creditor can also bring a claim in certain circumstances with the liquidator’s written consent or the court’s permission.
Keep dated cash forecasts, board minutes and adviser correspondence so the directors can show what information they had when the company took on a debt.
One client form. One finished return.
Your client completes one guided form. Tax Genie checks it, chases mistakes and sends the details to your engagement letter and tax software.
Made for Australian accounting firms