Changing Payroll Software for Client Employers 2026
Change an employer’s payroll software without duplicating income records. Reconcile employees, opening figures and STP treatment before the first pay.
- Published
- Updated
Changing payroll software mid-year is possible when you reconcile employee records and choose the correct Single Touch Payroll (STP) treatment before reporting from the new system.
This guide is for an accountant moving an Australian employer’s payroll. A supported import can bring employee details across. Review opening figures and reporting identifiers separately. Duplicating year-to-date income is the main reporting risk.
Choose the Cutover and Reporting Treatment
Choose the last pay in the old system and the first pay in the new system before moving balances. Record both pay periods and payment dates so the handover leaves no gap or overlapping payment.
A move from MYOB to Xero is one documented example. MYOB provides payroll and STP reports for reconciliation. Xero provides migration filing for previous software and employee identifiers after opening balances are entered.
Keep the employer’s ABN and branch beside the old and new business management software (BMS) IDs. Add each employee’s old and new STP Payroll ID. An internal employee number can differ from their STP Payroll ID.
The ATO identifies income statements using the combination of these identifiers. Transferring year-to-date (YTD) amounts under changed identifiers requires the correct notification. Its STP guidance sets out the available methods.
Select One Reporting Method
| Method | Treatment of amounts before cutover | Required reporting result |
|---|---|---|
| Replacement method | Transfer YTD figures to the new software | An update event reports the previous identifiers so the ATO replaces the old income statement |
| Zeroing-out method | First report zero YTD amounts from the old software, then transfer the actual figures | The old income statement stops displaying and the new software reports the transferred amounts |
| No YTD transfer | Keep pre-cutover income in the old reporting record | Each identifier combination has its own income statement and needs finalisation |
Use only a method the relevant product supports. Replacement requires the previous identifiers. Zeroing out requires access to the old software and its supported procedure. Under replacement, previous identifiers belong in an update event, not a pay event.
A change of ABN or branch needs separate treatment: finalise the original ABN or branch and start from zero under the new one. Do not treat a change of employer as an ordinary software transfer.
In the MYOB-to-Xero example, Xero’s documented migration filing reports previous BMS and employee Payroll IDs. Record that choice before importing balances. Do not also zero the old figures as an extra precaution.
Keep the Old File Available
Before cutover, confirm who can administer payroll, authorise bank payments and lodge STP for the employer. Preserve the old reports, declarations and submission outcomes before any subscription or access change.
Keep the existing payroll running if the destination cannot calculate a required pay item or the opening records remain unresolved. A software preference does not justify an unreviewed pay run.
Agree who owns each task, including timesheet approval and super payments. Record any overlapping subscriptions and the access needed for corrections before cancelling the old service. Tell employees where future payslips will appear.
Reconcile the Employee Opening Records
Reconcile each employee’s destination record against the old payroll reports and the last accepted STP figures. A matching total for the employer can hide an amount allocated to the wrong person.
Xero’s Australian payroll information describes spreadsheet employee imports and entering opening balances or past earnings. Treat the import as the start of setup. Inspect every imported field before the first pay.
For a destination using MYOB Business payroll, its setup guide puts previously paid amounts in employee pay history. It also requires pay and leave setup. Follow the instructions for the actual destination product.
Build the Opening Record Map
| Record | Source evidence | Review in the destination |
|---|---|---|
| Employee identity | Employee record and STP identifier list | Correct person, employment basis and old/new Payroll IDs |
| Earnings and withholding | Payroll detail reports and accepted STP summaries | Correct YTD amounts, income type and reporting categories |
| Deductions | Deduction reports and employee authorities | Correct balance and ongoing treatment |
| Leave | Leave balance and transaction reports | Correct units, opening balance and accrual rules |
| Superannuation | Contribution reports, fund details and payment records | Correct fund/member match, liability and amounts already paid |
| Payment details | Approved bank instructions and prior payment records | Correct account, payment method and approver |
| Previous payslips and declarations | Retained source documents | Accessible archive, with any missing destination history identified |
For each opening figure, record its source report, destination field and reviewer. Preserve the report’s period and employee identifier with the mapping. Mark an item complete only after the destination agrees with its source.
Map pay items by their treatment, not just their names. An allowance, reimbursement and ordinary earnings can need different reporting. Recreate required settings when an import does not carry them.
MYOB’s reconciliation guidance distinguishes payroll totals from STP gross amounts. Non-taxable deductions or items outside ATO reporting categories can explain a difference. Write the reconciliation rather than forcing unlike totals to match.
Work Through a Fictional Employee
Assume a fictional employee has $24,000 gross earnings and $5,000 withholding before cutover. Under the chosen replacement method, the reviewed opening record carries these amounts into the destination.
A new pay adds $2,000 gross and $400 withholding. The expected YTD result is $26,000 gross and $5,400 withholding. These are illustrative amounts, not a tax calculation.
If the old $24,000 remains a separate income record while the new record reports $26,000, the combined $50,000 signals duplicated reporting. Compare identifiers and migration filing before changing payroll amounts.
Check leave separately. With 60 opening hours, three hours accrued and eight hours taken, the expected closing balance is 55 hours. A correct earnings balance does not prove leave transferred correctly.
Verify the First Pay and Reported Result
Approve the first pay calculation before releasing money, then confirm the reported outcome after STP processing. A successful import or submission message does not prove that employees were paid or reported correctly.
- Compare the pay preview with approved hours, rates and pay items. Recalculate gross pay and each deduction, then check net pay and leave movements against the opening record map.
- Review bank details and the payment total before authorisation. After payment, match the bank result to the payroll payment record and identify rejected or unpaid amounts.
- Reconcile super liability with the approved pay and opening position. Check contribution payment records separately so an opening liability is neither missed nor paid twice.
- Confirm the migration notification and first STP report reach the accepted status for the chosen method. Compare reported employee categories and YTD figures with the reviewed payroll result.
Complete Xero replacement filing before the first Xero pay. Open Payroll, then Single Touch Payroll and Tools. Start migration filing, enter the previous BMS and employee Payroll IDs, select the employees and complete the declaration after review.
Xero says the migration filing status becomes Filed once the ATO accepts it. Check that outcome on the STP Overview page before treating the identifier transfer as complete.
Recover From a Difference
If Xero migration filing fails, open its filing history and inspect the error. Correct the identified details through its resubmission process. Retain the rejected response and the accepted replacement together.
If income is duplicated, compare the actual identifier combinations with the chosen reporting method. Two statements can be correct under the no-transfer method. Under replacement, check whether the previous IDs were accepted before altering financial figures.
For missing or incorrect employee amounts, reconcile the last accepted YTD report to payroll and use the ATO correction procedure. Employer-level withholding corrections can also affect activity statement reporting.
Pause the next report if the error’s cause remains unresolved. Escalate with the employer’s identifiers, affected Payroll IDs, reconciliation and submission response. Keep employee records in the employer’s authorised support channel.
Retain source access while corrections remain open. Record the accepted correction and compare the final reported result with the agreed migration treatment. Close the handover only when each opening difference and first-pay exception has an owner and a resolved outcome.
One client form. One finished return.
Your client completes one guided form. Tax Genie checks it, chases mistakes and sends the details to your engagement letter and tax software.
Made for Australian accounting firms