Cash vs Accrual Accounting for Client Records
Choose a defensible income-recognition method for your client. Compare receipts and earnings, then distinguish the income-tax method from GST reporting.
- Published
- Updated
Cash accounting recognises income when received. Accrual accounting recognises income when earned. For income tax, choose the method that correctly reflects the client’s income, then assess accounts and GST separately.
A small-business label does not settle the income-tax method. The work performed, contractual payment rights and way the business earns income determine the answer.
Receipts and Earnings Methods Compared
The receipts method brings income to account on actual or constructive receipt. Constructive receipt includes money dealt with on the taxpayer’s behalf or as they direct.
Under the earnings method, income is derived when a recoverable debt arises. That generally means the taxpayer has a legal entitlement to an ascertainable amount for the agreed work. The contract helps determine when that entitlement exists.
An invoice can record that entitlement, but issuing an invoice alone does not establish that income has been earned. Advance payments and incomplete work need their own assessment.
One Sale Across Two Income Years
Consider a fictional service business. It finishes an agreed job before the end of Year 1 and becomes entitled to $8,000, excluding GST. Its customer pays the full amount in Year 2.
Assume the amount is ordinary income and no specific provision changes the result. The ATO’s accounting-method guidance explains the timing distinction.
| Point in the transaction | Receipts method | Earnings method |
|---|---|---|
| Work completed and recoverable debt created in Year 1 | No income from the unpaid amount yet | $8,000 income in Year 1 |
| Year 1 ends with the invoice unpaid | Record the outstanding invoice for collection | Carry the $8,000 receivable in the records |
| Customer pays in Year 2 | $8,000 income in Year 2 | Receipt clears the receivable without creating the same income again |
The comparison shows the consequence of each method. It does not give the business a free choice between them. Keep debtor records even when the income-tax calculation uses receipts.
Select the Method That Reflects the Client’s Income
Select the income-tax method from the client’s circumstances and each relevant income activity. TR 98/1 asks which method gives a substantially correct reflection of income.
For an individual earning income mainly from their own skills or services, receipts can be appropriate. Trading or manufacturing generally points to earnings. Staff who generate income, equipment and reliance on stock can change the assessment.
Build the Decision From the Records
- Describe how the business earns income. Separate the owner’s work from sales of stock and work performed by employees.
- Read the customer terms. Identify when payment becomes an entitlement and how the business extends credit or collects debts.
- Assess the resources producing income. Record the contribution of employees, equipment and circulating capital, including consumables.
- Explain the selected method. Address facts pointing the other way and assess separate activities where their differences affect the result.
Company business income generally points to the earnings method. Incorporation needs consideration even when the underlying service looks similar to a sole practitioner’s work.
A fictional sole practitioner who personally performs the work presents different facts from a business selling stock on credit through employees. A shared turnover figure does not erase those differences.
Incorrect: Apply receipts to every business that qualifies for small-business concessions.
Correct: Assess income derivation from the business facts, then consider each concession’s separate eligibility rules.
The way the books are kept is relevant evidence. A software setting cannot replace the assessment of when income is derived.
Separate Tax, Accounts and GST Decisions
Maintain a separate recorded basis for financial statements, income tax and GST. Each answers a different question, even when the records come from the same bookkeeping file.
Financial Statements
For financial statements governed by AASB 101, paragraph 27 requires accrual accounting except for cash flow information. Apply the reporting framework relevant to the client and reporting period.
Financial-reporting revenue recognition and income-tax derivation can differ. An accrual set of accounts therefore needs a tax reconciliation when the appropriate tax treatment differs from the accounting treatment.
Income Tax
An income-tax method determines when ordinary income is derived. Specific tax provisions can override the general approach. Expense deductions also require their own tax analysis, including capital and prepayment rules.
In the fictional $8,000 example, suppose accrual accounts recognise the revenue in Year 1 while receipts is the supported income-tax method. The Year 1 tax reconciliation removes the unpaid $8,000 from accounting income.
When payment arrives in Year 2, the tax reconciliation adds $8,000 if the receipt creates assessable income without current-year accounting revenue. Retain the invoice reference across both years so the adjustment reverses once.
GST
GST accounting eligibility has separate rules. Businesses with aggregated turnover below $10 million can choose cash accounting for GST. Other eligibility routes also exist, including using cash accounting for income tax.
That turnover threshold does not establish a right to use receipts for income tax. A business can have accrual accounts and earnings-based income tax while using cash accounting for GST.
On the cash basis, GST attribution follows payment, including part payments. Under the ordinary non-cash rule, issuing an invoice or receiving payment can trigger attribution before the income-tax earnings point.
Keep a GST reconciliation of amounts reported and amounts still awaiting attribution. Use GST-exclusive income figures where appropriate so GST collected is not counted as sales income in the tax calculation.
Document a Change of Method
Review an income-tax method when the client’s circumstances change enough to make the existing method inappropriate. TR 98/1 supports consistency while that method remains appropriate.
An expanding service business that begins relying on staff or trading stock needs a new assessment. A lower tax result alone does not establish that a method change is appropriate.
Prepare a Transition Workpaper
- Record the old and new methods, the affected income activities and the reason for the change. Identify the period from which the new treatment applies.
- Reconcile opening debtors to the final records under the old method. For each invoice, show what income has already been returned and what remains unpaid.
- Trace subsequent receipts to those opening invoices. Separate receipts already assessed from current-period income and investigate differences before completing the return.
- Assess each opening adjustment under the applicable tax law. Keep accounting opening entries separate from tax adjustments and document the authority for each inclusion or exclusion.
- Reconcile the transition schedule to the new return and closing debtor list. Have the reviewer check unusual balances and confirm that each receipt has a documented treatment.
For example, if $8,000 was already assessed under earnings, a later bank receipt must not be added again solely because receipts now applies. Mark the receipt against the previously assessed invoice in the transition schedule.
In the opposite direction, flag opening debtors that were never assessed under receipts. Determine their tax treatment explicitly. An opening accounting journal does not, by itself, create assessable income or authorise a catch-up amount.
Treat a GST method change separately. For a change from cash to non-cash GST accounting, the ATO requires a tax-period boundary and adjustments for previously unreported sales and unclaimed purchases.
Before finalising the first return under the changed income-tax method, trace opening debtors through to collections and the tax reconciliation. Every remaining difference needs an explanation and a stated tax treatment.
One client form. One finished return.
Your client completes one guided form. Tax Genie checks it, chases mistakes and sends the details to your engagement letter and tax software.
Made for Australian accounting firms