Types of Business Fraud in Client Records

Unexplained entries need evidence, not an accusation. Recognise business fraud patterns in client records and document the checks your engagement permits.

Published
Updated

Business fraud can appear as invented revenue, fictitious supplier costs, diverted assets or concealed liabilities. Treat unexplained entries as reasons for documented enquiries, without assuming intent.

An error and a deliberate misstatement can produce the same accounting entry. The supporting transaction, explanation and evidence determine what you can conclude.

Fraud Patterns in the Books

Fraud involves intentional deception. An incorrect entry alone does not establish that intention. ASA 240 distinguishes fraudulent financial reporting from misappropriation of assets in an audit of a financial report.

Use these fictional entries to identify what needs checking. The amounts exclude GST to keep the examples focused on the accounting inconsistency.

PatternFictional entry or omissionEvidence to requestAlternative explanation to test
Revenue manipulationDebit receivables $18,000, credit sales $18,000 for an invoice with no apparent deliveryCustomer order, contract, delivery evidence and later credit notesA genuine invoice posted in the wrong period
Fictitious supplierDebit repairs $7,500, credit payables $7,500 for a supplier with no work recordSupplier invoice, purchase authority, service evidence and payment detailsA genuine contractor whose work record was filed elsewhere
Diverted assetsDebit equipment $12,000, credit bank $12,000, but the asset cannot be locatedPurchase invoice, serial number, delivery location and asset registerEquipment held at another authorised site
Concealed liabilityA $9,000 supplier invoice for completed work is omitted from payables and expensesSupplier statement, invoice, receipt of services and later paymentAn invoice received after the accounts were prepared

If an invoice is invented to increase reported sales, the records contain deliberate revenue manipulation. If a genuine invoice lands in the wrong period by mistake, the issue is an error requiring correction.

Grant Thornton’s employee-fraud guidance describes doctored invoices and ghost suppliers. A payment to a supplier with a genuine name still needs evidence of the goods or services.

Repeated round-dollar journals, unexplained reversals and missing source documents are financial statement red flags. They identify entries to examine. They do not establish who benefited or whether a person acted dishonestly.

Check the Evidence

Trace each exception from the accounting entry through the invoice and bank record to the underlying transaction. Record what agrees, what conflicts and what remains unavailable.

  1. Save the original export and supporting files within your authorised access. Record when you obtained them and the system or person supplying them.
  2. Identify the entry number, account, amount and reporting period. Include the preparer and approval history where available.
  3. Match the invoice to the purchase or sales authority and evidence of delivery. Compare the amount and counterparty with the bank transaction.
  4. Obtain an explanation through the appropriate client contact. Record the explanation separately from documents that corroborate it.
  5. Decide whether the evidence resolves the accounting treatment or requires escalation. Identify any affected return or financial report before continuing that work.

For a supplier exception, inspect the supplier record and changes to its payment details. Where your authority permits independent confirmation, use an established contact route separate from the disputed invoice.

The Western Australian Auditor General’s supplier master file guide describes duplicate records, diverted payments and change histories. Its public-sector examples help identify checks relevant to a client’s supplier records.

A bank statement establishes that money moved. It does not by itself establish that repairs occurred, that equipment belongs to the business or that the recipient supplied anything.

Preserve the source files when preparing an adjustment. Keep the proposed correction, approval and explanation alongside them so the original entry remains traceable. Avoid overwriting a disputed invoice with an edited copy.

For companies, ASIC’s financial reporting guidance explains directors’ responsibility for records that correctly explain transactions and financial position. An accountant’s enquiries support the engagement without transferring that responsibility.

Stay Within the Engagement

A tax or bookkeeping engagement permits enquiries needed for its agreed work. It does not automatically include a forensic investigation or provide an audit opinion.

Define the question you need to resolve. Checking whether an expense has support differs from establishing who created a false document or quantifying every loss.

ASA 240 governs auditors’ responsibilities for fraud in a financial report audit. If you undertake an audit, apply the version operative for that reporting period. Its audit procedures do not automatically define an ordinary tax engagement.

For professional accountants in public practice, APES 110 addresses suspected non-compliance with laws and regulations. Section 360 distinguishes audit and other professional services and requires consideration of further action.

Escalate the exception to the engagement partner before approaching a person suspected of manipulating the records. If that person controls access, obtain independent legal advice about preservation and the appropriate communication route.

An uninvolved director or those charged with governance can be the appropriate recipient. Establish their role and authority before sharing the file. Assess safety and any legal restriction on communication.

Confidentiality continues during the enquiry. The Tax Practitioners Board (TPB) explains that non-compliance provisions do not authorise unlawful disclosure. Record the legal basis or client permission before disclosing information externally.

Registered tax practitioners must also address false or misleading statements. The TPB’s rules contain separate conditions for correction advice, withdrawal and notification. A suspicious entry alone does not trigger every requirement.

Where the applicable conditions are met, advise the client about correction and the consequences of inaction. Continued recklessness or intentional disregard can require withdrawal, subject to the prescribed conditions and exceptions.

Notification has additional conditions, including the substantial-harm test. Assess those requirements against the actual statement and client response, with legal advice where needed. Keep the decision and its reasons in the engagement file.

If specialist investigation is needed, agree its authority and scope before expanding the work. Identify who appoints the investigator and how evidence will be preserved.

Document the Conclusion

Record the inconsistency and the evidence supporting your decision in neutral language. Separate established facts from explanations and unresolved questions.

The following review note is fictional. It concerns the $7,500 repairs entry in the table.

Review fieldFictional file note
Engagement and exceptionTax return preparation. Repairs expense of $7,500 lacks evidence of completed work.
Evidence obtainedLedger entry R417, invoice S082 and bank payment agree on the amount. No service report is in the supplied files.
Client explanationThe office manager states that the repairs occurred at a second site. This explanation remains uncorroborated.
Unresolved factsWhether the work occurred, which site received it and who approved the supplier remain unconfirmed.
Present conclusionThe expense is unsupported on the evidence obtained. Intent and fraud are not established.
Next decisionEngagement partner to request site evidence and approval records, then decide the return treatment and whether specialist advice is required.

Assign the outstanding request to a named person and set a response deadline. When evidence arrives, add the result to the note and record who approves the accounting or return treatment.

If records remain unavailable, decide whether you can complete the affected work and what professional obligations follow. Preserve the unresolved issue in the file instead of closing it with an unsupported accusation or assurance.

One client form. One finished return.

Your client completes one guided form. Tax Genie checks it, chases mistakes and sends the details to your engagement letter and tax software.

See how Tax Genie works

Made for Australian accounting firms

Tax GenieSee how Tax Genie works