Authenticator App: Choosing One for Your Practice

Compare Microsoft Authenticator, Google Authenticator and Authy for a practice’s logins, then set one up, move it to a new phone and fix codes that fail.

Published
Updated

Use Microsoft Authenticator for Microsoft 365 approval prompts. When staff use sign-in codes, make sure they can recover access if they lose a phone.

Choose an Authenticator App

An authenticator app supplies the second factor after your password in two-factor authentication (2FA). The password is something you know. The code or approval shows you can use a device registered to the account.

For Microsoft 365, use Microsoft Authenticator if your administrator requires its approvals. For logins that accept time-based one-time passwords (TOTP), choose Google Authenticator for optional Google Account sync or Authy for password-protected backups across registered devices.

AppBackupMultiple DevicesPush ApprovalsApp Subscription
Microsoft AuthenticatorBacks up eligible codes on the same phone operating system. For work accounts it saves the name only.Register each phone separately for the work account.Supported for Microsoft accounts where the organisation allows it. Other sites use codes.No separate subscription
Google AuthenticatorSaves codes to your Google Account if you sign in. You can also keep codes on the phone.Codes saved to the same Google Account sync to other signed-in devices.Generates codes. Google sign-in prompts are a separate method.No separate subscription
AuthyEncrypted code backups require a backup password.Multi-Device and Backups let codes sync across registered devices.Ordinary QR-code accounts use codes. Twilio’s legacy OneTouch approvals require a service that already supports them.No separate subscription for staff use

Microsoft Entra licensing determines which policies you can enforce. For Xero push approvals, use Xero Verify. Other authenticator apps use codes. Xero’s sign-in methods

Use a passkey or hardware security key for administrator and payment accounts where supported. These methods bind sign-in to the real site. A fake site can collect a one-time code. Australian Signals Directorate guidance on passkeys

Protect the Practice’s Logins to Client Data

Require two-step sign-in on every staff account that can see client data. Start with Microsoft 365 email and file storage, Xero, tax software and the client portal. Include payroll, shared document storage and accounts that can change staff access.

In the Microsoft Entra admin centre, open Entra ID, then Overview and Properties. Select Manage security defaults and set it to Enabled. Security defaults require staff to register for multi-factor authentication (MFA) and prompt for it when required.

With an Entra ID P1 or P2 licence, you can use Conditional Access instead. Test the Require multifactor authentication for all users template in report-only mode before enforcing it. Microsoft 365 MFA setup

Xero prompts each person with access to a paying subscription to set up MFA on their own login. For other services, turn on the organisation-wide MFA requirement where available. Require individual enrolment wherever the setting is per user.

Keep one row per person and service. Record the MFA requirement, registration status, backup method type and date you verified sign-in. Use the Entra registration report if your licence includes it. Microsoft’s authentication methods report

Set Up the App for a Staff Member

Start while the staff member can still sign in to the service. Use a device your practice permits and keep the existing browser session open until the new method works.

  1. Install the chosen app from the phone’s official app store.
  2. Sign in to the service in a browser and open its security settings. Select the authenticator app option to display the setup QR code.
  3. Add the account in the app and scan the code. Enter the current code in the browser or complete the test approval when prompted.
  4. Add a backup sign-in method that remains available if the phone is lost. If the service issues one-time recovery codes, keep them in restricted storage accessible without the phone. Keep setup QR codes out of email and chat.
  5. Start a fresh sign-in and check that the new app works before closing the original session.

For Microsoft 365, open Security info and add Microsoft Authenticator if your practice uses it. Microsoft’s account setup instructions

In Xero, open your account settings to set up multi-factor authentication. Xero can use a backup email address or security questions.

Move an Authenticator to a New Phone

Keep the old phone available until the new phone can complete a fresh sign-in to every protected account. How you move the codes depends on how the old app stored them.

Microsoft Authenticator

  1. On the old iPhone, turn on iCloud Drive, iCloud Keychain and iCloud Backup. Turn on Authenticator under Saved to iCloud. On the new iPhone, use the same iCloud account and settings. Open Authenticator to check the restored codes.
  2. On the old Android phone, check Cloud Backup in Authenticator and note the recovery account. On the new Android phone, choose Restore from backup and sign in with that account.
  3. If you switch between iPhone and Android, add your accounts again.
  4. Re-register your Microsoft 365 work account from Security info. Test that the new phone receives the approval, then remove the old phone’s registration. Microsoft’s restore instructions

Google Authenticator

  1. For synced codes, sign in to the same Google Account in Google Authenticator on the new phone. Check that your entries appear.
  2. For codes stored on the old phone, open Menu, then Transfer accounts and Export accounts. Select the entries to move.
  3. On the new phone, open Transfer accounts and choose Import accounts. Scan the transfer QR codes from the old phone and check each sign-in. Google’s transfer instructions

Authy

  1. On the old phone, check that Backups and Multi-Device are enabled and that you know your backup password.
  2. On the new phone, register Authy under the same phone number. Verify the registration by SMS or on the old device, then enter your backup password to unlock the backed-up codes.
  3. After testing the new phone, remove the old device from Authy and disable further device additions. If the phone number is also changing, use Authy’s phone number change option while you still have access.

If you need to reconnect Xero, open Account, then Additional Security. Choose Change under Connected device. Complete the new setup and verify a fresh Xero sign-in before resetting the old phone. Xero’s connected-device instructions

When the Codes Do Not Work

If an authenticator code fails, check that you opened the entry for the right service and work account. Wait for a fresh code and enter it before it changes. Set the phone’s date and time to automatic.

An app that generates time-based codes relies on the phone’s clock. If the clock drifts, the service can reject the code even though you entered it correctly. Google’s guidance on authenticator codes

If a push prompt goes to your old phone, check which device is registered and whether notifications are allowed on the new one. Approve only a request from a sign-in you started. Microsoft’s authenticator troubleshooting

If you lose your phone, use a recovery code or another registered method. For Xero, choose the backup email or security questions you set up. Then enrol the replacement device. Xero’s recovery instructions

If you cannot use a backup method for Microsoft 365, ask your practice administrator to verify your identity and help you re-register. For other services, use their account recovery steps. Microsoft’s administrator recovery guidance

If you lose your Authy phone with Multi-Device turned off and have no other registered device, use Authy’s account recovery. Unbacked codes or codes you cannot decrypt must be set up again with each service.

Remove the lost phone from the account’s registered methods once you have access. If someone else might have the phone, tell your practice’s IT contact promptly so they can assess whether to revoke active sessions.

One client form. One finished return.

Your client completes one guided form. Tax Genie checks it, chases mistakes and sends the details to your engagement letter and tax software.

See how Tax Genie works

Made for Australian accounting firms

Tax GenieSee how Tax Genie works