Accountant vs Financial Adviser 2026
Compare accountants and financial advisers. Check the service, authority and records your practice needs before giving advice or referring a client.
- Published
- Updated
An accountant prepares accounts and may advise on tax. A financial adviser recommends financial products within their authorisation. A client’s request can call for both services.
What an Accountant and Financial Adviser Do
Start with the work the client wants. Preparing financial statements or modelling cash flow is accounting work. Advising a client on a tax liability they’ll rely on to meet their obligations is generally a tax agent service.
Financial product advice includes an opinion or recommendation that is intended, or could reasonably be seen as intended, to influence a decision about a financial product.
The product can be a specific fund or a class of products.
Advice is personal when you consider the client’s objectives, financial situation or needs. A reasonable expectation that you’ll consider any of those factors also makes the advice personal.
General advice also falls within the financial product advice rules. Factual information can sit outside those rules. Check whether your wording or the context implies a recommendation.
For a client reviewing their super, a tax agent can assess the tax treatment of a proposed contribution. An appropriately authorised financial adviser can assess whether a change of fund suits the client.
A tax lawyer can advise on how the law applies to contested facts or represent the client in a tax dispute. Your practice can reconcile an amended assessment while the lawyer advises on grounds for challenging it.
Check the Practice’s Advice Permissions
Check who will give each part of the advice, what they’re authorised to do and whether the engagement covers that work.
- For paid tax agent services, check tax agent registration for the entity the client engaged and any conditions that limit the work. Confirm who supervises staff delivering the service.
- For financial product advice, check the Australian financial services (AFS) licence and the person’s authority under it. Match the service, product and client type to that authority. A limited licence covers only the services and products it authorises.
- For a relevant provider giving personal advice to retail clients on relevant products, check registration on the Financial Advisers Register. ASIC also sets professional standards covering qualifications, the adviser exam, continuing professional development and conduct.
- Check the professional body’s public practice rules. CPA Australia and Chartered Accountants Australia and New Zealand have public practice certificate requirements for members in applicable roles. The certificate addresses membership obligations. Check the statutory registrations and licences separately.
A relevant provider giving paid tax (financial) advice as part of personal advice to retail clients must be a qualified tax relevant provider (QTRP). Check their status and tax advice details on the Financial Advisers Register.
ASIC’s QTRP guidance explains the commercial law and tax law course requirements and exemptions, including for registered tax agents.
The QTRP qualification applies to tax advice within that financial advice service. Check Tax Practitioners Board requirements separately for standalone tax agent work and non-relevant providers giving paid tax (financial) advice.
Tax Explanation or Product Recommendation
A client asks what tax consequences follow if they sell units they already hold. In this fictional example, the tax agent calculates the likely capital gain under stated assumptions and keeps the advice to tax.
The same client then asks which managed fund they ought to buy with the proceeds. Recommending a fund based on their needs would be personal financial product advice. Direct that question to an adviser whose authorisation covers it.
Regulation 7.1.29(4) provides a limited exemption for certain advice about the tax implications of financial products.
Keep any product advice incidental to the tax advice. A separate recommendation on the merits of a financial product falls outside the exemption.
Check for benefits triggered by a client acquiring a product named in the advice or in a class it names.
The exemption is unavailable if you receive such a benefit from anyone other than the client or their associate.
If the tax advice also constitutes financial product advice to a retail client, give them the required written statement with the advice. ASIC explains the modified wording for licensees and representatives advising outside their authorisation.
Scope, Refer and Retain the Decision
Put the agreed work and the referral in writing before your practice answers the client’s question.
- Record the client’s request and the decision they want help with. Note the product or proposed transaction and which parts fall within your practice’s authority.
- Confirm what your practice will answer in the engagement letter or scope change. Assign the tax analysis to a named practitioner and refer the product recommendation to an appropriately authorised adviser.
- Agree who contacts the adviser and which records the adviser needs. Obtain and record the client’s permission before sharing information about their affairs unless a legal duty requires disclosure.
- Record what you sent, to whom and when. Confirm who will report each conclusion to the client. If the other adviser’s assumptions change, revisit any tax advice that relied on them.
Each practice remains responsible for the work it performs. Keep the engagement terms, client instructions, calculations, advice you delivered and the documents you relied on.
Where another adviser contributed, record which facts or assumptions you took from their work and how they affected your advice.
Registered tax practitioners must retain records of tax agent services for at least five years after the service is provided. Keep enough detail to show its nature, scope and outcome under the Tax Practitioners Board’s record-keeping guidance.
For personal advice to retail clients, the AFS licensee must keep the applicable advice records accessible for at least seven years from the day the advice was given.
ASIC Regulatory Guide 175 sets out what the file must show, including the basis for the advice. Keep the Statement of Advice or applicable Record of Advice with the supporting material.
Before closing the file, check that a colleague can see who supplied each part of the advice. The same file must show the client’s referral consent and the assumptions your practice relied on.
One client form. One finished return.
Your client completes one guided form. Tax Genie checks it, chases mistakes and sends the details to your engagement letter and tax software.
Made for Australian accounting firms